Opponents of NB Power gas plant project shocked & disheartened by council vote

A grim-faced Juliette Bulmer talks to reporters after last night’s meeting

Opponents of the big, gas/diesel generating plant that NB Power wants built on the Chignecto Isthmus seemed shocked Tuesday night after Tantramar Town Council voted against calling for the immediate cancellation of the project.

Midgic resident Juliette Bulmer told reporters that there seemed to be good support for the town opposing the project as Councillors Michael Tower, Bruce Phinney, Allison Butcher and Josh Goguen spoke out against it.

“And then all of a sudden it took a wrong turn,” she said, “and unfortunately, the majority ruled to support Mayor Black.”

During the meeting, Black moved a motion to delay the vote until the next regular council meeting on October 14th and when his motion was defeated, he argued that opposing the project was outside council’s jurisdiction.

“I hate to say it, but that’s not right,” Bulmer said, “because a lot of this will affect the health of community members.”

She referred to Councillor Tower’s statement during the meeting that when he wanted council to speak out against the threatened closure of Sackville’s hospital, he was told that was outside its mandate.

“If health isn’t part of the mandate of this municipality, then there’s a problem,” Tower said.

Bulmer agrees.

“What the hell is going to happen when this plant releases its toxic pollution, contaminates the water, emits greenhouse gases way above anything that should be and is acceptable?” she asked.

“What about the health of the community then?”

Councillor Martin explains his vote

Greg Martin, the only councillor who did not speak during the meeting, told reporters afterwards that he was following his mother’s advice to learn by listening to others.

He also explained why he voted against Councillor Tower’s motion to send a letter to Premier Holt with copies to other officials urging the immediate cancellation of the gas plant project.

“The reason why I voted against sending the letter is because I don’t know enough about the project,” he said.

He added that he wasn’t able to attend any meetings which would have included the two open houses that the American company PROENERGY held in Sackville during August.

“I don’t want to make a long statement,” Martin said, “about something that I don’t really  know a whole lot about.”

Coalition to protect Chignecto Isthmus

AWI Executive Director Barry Rothfuss talking to CBC reporter Erica Butler after last night’s council meeting

Barry Rothfuss, executive director of the Atlantic Wildlife Institute, said council’s lack of support for protecting the sensitive environment on the Isthmus is disheartening.

“We found out today that they’ve got the permits to start drilling wells to do the water testing which is the beginning of damaging the ecosystem,” he said, adding that he’s also heard that PROENERGY will start building a new access road next week into the 50-acre gas plant site.

“At the same time, we’ve got a premier telling us publicly that she’s concerned and taking our concerns to heart and telling us there’s a lot of questions that need to be answered,” Rothfuss said.

“She’s doing nothing to slow down the process and making it so that the questions that she potentially claims she’s asking are going to be answered after the fact and the damage will already be done.”

Rothfuss is co-ordinating a coalition of more than 15 groups to defend the Chignecto Isthmus.

He says the combined knowledge in the coalition will be used to inform decision makers at every level including the municipal one.

“Let’s bring it to them, bring it wholeheartedly to them with the voices of the people that have that expertise,” he says.

To read today’s news release announcing formation of the coalition, click here.

For coverage of the strategy meeting that led to its formation, click here.

To read a transcript of the town council debate, click here.

For CBC coverage, click here.

This entry was posted in climate change, Town of Tantramar and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Opponents of NB Power gas plant project shocked & disheartened by council vote

  1. Bruno says:

    A little inside baseball: The Mayor is hoping to run as a Liberal MLA in the near future. He’ll never do anything against the provincial government because he wants to run. No backbone. Absolute self interest. He represents US, not himself and his ambitions.

  2. Wayne Feindel says:

    There are no repesentatives in the new system . They speak with one voice or not at all. No one is in an advocacy position. It’s fake. A little research will show many failures of the CARVER model. The fine print in the new act is quite clear that the province decides the good of the whole province. I call it the indefinite good. I say march on corporate Tantramar and insist any councillor (acting as a corporate director) who takes your money without standing up for their ward needs to resign.

  3. ““The reason why I voted against sending the letter is because I don’t know enough about the project,” he said.

    He added that he wasn’t able to attend either of the two open houses that the American company PROENERGY held in Sackville during August.

    “I don’t want to make a long statement,” Martin said, “about something that I don’t really know a whole lot about.””

    I find it seriously hard to believe that Counsillor Martin “knows nothing” about this subject. Considering how front page – as it were – it has been since July, for him to be so uninformed means he’s either been vacant over the entire summer, hasn’t seen the local news nor talked to anyone, or he hasn’t bothered TO look into a subject that is obviously important locally.

    Either excuse does not give a good impression. Considering the area of Tantramar he represents – which is smack dab in the Isthmus – one would think he would know something by now about it. At LEAST the research is there online to look at both sides of the issue.

    And if truly ignorant of the topic, instead a vote of ‘no’ against the proposal, an abstain from voting should have been the choice.

    At this point, it truly seems that a good chunk of the council doesn’t seem to give any consideration to the people who live in this town and their thoughts/impressions of this topic.

  4. Wayne Feindel says:

    Elane everyone can stop bickering and squabbling. Now that you know [OWNER] not citizen and the Elected officials know also that their positions are geographic places only.
    Actual quote from Carver. Directors/Councillors once elected and enlightened if they were to accept petitioners from the folks, “would be knowedge listening to ignorance.” We can’t have that. Where is the outrage about corportism taking over deliberative boards.

Leave a Reply to Elaine MacDonaldCancel reply