Midgic meeting discusses how to stop proposed 500 MW gas plant on Chignecto Isthmus

Terry Jones (L) and Juliette Bulmer along with Kristen Nicole LeBlanc organized Monday’s meeting

About 80 people gathered in the basement of the Midgic Baptist Church Monday night to discuss ways of stopping NB Power from building a massive natural gas generating plant near Centre Village on the ecologically sensitive Chignecto Isthmus.

“Ultimately, the biggest impact that we’re going to find is going to come to our wetlands, our water and our wells,” said meeting organizer Terry Jones whose 178 acre family property is only 1.4 kilometres from the proposed 500 MW gas plant.

“And this water damage is going to travel all the way to the Tantramar River, to Sackville, to the aquifers down there. So to think that it’s just a Centre Village project, that’s just the tip of the iceberg,” she added.

“What we need to do is look at slowing this project down for sure so that we have time,” Jones said, “because if everything passes through, they’re going to start in the fall drilling test wells, and in January, first quarter of next year, building and starting the infrastructure.”

“It’s not that we’re anti-progress or anti-development. Not at all,” meeting organizer and Midgic resident Juliette Bulmer told the meeting.

“It’s just such a sensitive area right here. It’s one of the few corridors where we have the migratory birds, the moose project and all kinds of things,” she added.

“A lot of you have been living on the land for a long time. You’ve got generations of families and you know what it’s been like living here,” Bulmer said as someone in the audience called out, “The water is so good here.”

“The water is so good here,” Bulmer repeated.

“We have a right to have clean water, clean air and to enjoy our property,” Jones said adding there’s potential for safe, eco-friendly tourism in the area.

“But, we’re looking at building a concrete pad up there and sticking in generating stations.”

No ‘confidence’ in province

Tantramar MLA Megan Mitton

Tantramar MLA Megan Mitton reported on the provincial environment minister’s response to her letter calling for a comprehensive environmental impact assessment (EIA) that would require extensive public consultations.

She said Gilles LePage wrote back to say he would not decide on whether to order a comprehensive EIA until initial reviews had been completed and he added: “It should be noted that Comprehensive reviews are generally required for large scale projects like mines, refineries, nuclear power, etc.”

“So, I don’t have confidence in the provincial government,” Mitton said.

She offered to use her constituency office to co-ordinate e-mail and telephone lists as a tool for organizing and sharing information. She said she will also present petitions against the project in the legislature, but warned it won’t meet until October and it’s easy for the government to ignore petitions.

Diesel dangers

Pam Novak and Barry Rothfuss of the Atlantic Wildlife Institute

Barry Rothfuss, executive director of the Atlantic Wildlife Institute (AWI), which would be 4.5 kilometres from the generating plant, spoke about his expertise in dealing with the environmental effects of projects like this.

AWI is the only organization in Atlantic Canada that is certified to deal with risks and threats to ecologically sensitive flora and fauna and the only one certified to suggest ways of mitigating damage when it occurs.

“I’ve been in a lot of facilities like this,” he said. “Just to access these facilities, you need special training. You need understanding of the environments you’re walking into.”

He added that the big, 10-generator plant will be using diesel fuel as a backup to natural gas and that would require a diesel storage capacity of three million gallons.

Rothfuss said if significant leaks occurred, local organizations would not have the capacity to deal with them.

“These types of facilities are notorious for leaks and things going wrong and human error,” he added.

In addition to AWI, speakers for the Canadian Parks and Wilderness Society and EOS Eco-Energy expressed their environmental concerns about the proposed gas and diesel plant.

Renewable alternatives

Leslie Chandler

Activist Leslie Chandler told the meeting there are alternatives to fossil fuels such as gas and diesel.

“There’s something called BESS which is battery energy storage systems. The cost of those systems has dropped 50% since 2022,” she said.

“And building one of those is cheaper than a gas plant,” she added referring to a report from the Clean Energy States Alliance in Maine.

Chandler noted that PROENERGY, the American company contracted to build and operate the gas plant, is holding open houses from 4 to 8 p.m. on Tuesday, August 12th at the Sackville Music Barn and on Wednesday, August 13th at the Tantramar Veterans Memorial Civic Centre.

She urged people to carry one message to company representatives.

“Say our community is not having this and we are going renewable. Yeah, we’re just not buying it, we’re not having it, it’s not happening here and we’re going renewable,” she concluded.

Meeting participants on one side of the church basement. A total of about 80 people attended the meeting

This entry was posted in climate change, Environment, Town of Tantramar and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Midgic meeting discusses how to stop proposed 500 MW gas plant on Chignecto Isthmus

  1. Margo Sheppard says:

    I am grateful for Bruce Wark and to all the activists who organized this meeting. We so often hear “Well this gas project x, y or z will produce lower emissions than burning oil” as if burning oil is the only alternative. It is the expedient alternative, full stop. And it is the unimaginative alternative produced by people steeped in traditional ways of doing business.

    But NB Power and any public agency should not entertain fossil fuel investments EVEN IF their calculations say they should. What about demand management? We don’t even have time of day pricing! And what about requiring new data centres in the province to use only renewables and storage? What about allowing new municipal power utilities to incorporate, so they can generate their own electricity, while putting profits into maintaining the entire grid?

    NB Power is OUR community power utility. Why does it never feel that way?

  2. Leslie Chandler says:

    Wow, Margo, you knocked it out of the park! And we’re so proud of Tantramarians, this is never going to fly. NB Power is an EPIC FAILURE, by DESIGN. Everyone knows this and everyone knows WHY!!! We hope Tantramar is the small community in NB that pushes over the first domino heading toward true ENERGY DEMOCRACY!! Leslie & Ron

  3. I just heard about this, this morning.

    https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/yukon-first-nation-celebrates-completion-solar-facility-1.7607452

    Amherst has it’s solar, too.

    There is no reason why these options shouldn’t be discussed and no excuse for it, either. Since we wouldn’t need that big a facility, it would take less time to build as well.

    Tonight’s conversation at the Civic Center should be… informative.

    • Leslie Chandler says:

      Fantastic, Elaine!! My husband heard that news clip on radio this morning. So great you raise it here! It’s coming, the community has to decide to take this direction and not the fossil one and then things will happen!! https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/north/yukon-first-nation-celebrates-completion-solar-facility-1.7607452

      • It’s just one question among quite a few I now have for these people and the answers I’m looking for aren’t just a dismissive “it won’t happen” as it was when the issue of a possible problem/disaster were to happen at the plant, what would be done.

        As an addendum, if NB Power had bothered to consider solar, they wouldn’t need that EXACT area because of the convenience of where the LNG and Power lines cross, rather they could build in a less volatile area and it would still be in our area meaning the 10 jobs that were mentioned in the initial discussion could still remain in Tantramar (though likely it’d be more than 10? I don’t know for sure).

        Hell, kill 2 birds with one stone; make the place where the solar panels will be a parking lot, allowing much needed parking spaces but also power generation. (hey, it’s an idea at least even if not the best one)

        All these people who were ‘thinking’ didn’t think too hard, IMO.

Leave a Reply to Margo SheppardCancel reply