Media get failing grade for coverage of N.B. fracking protests

Miles Howe outside Ottawa House

Miles Howe outside Ottawa House

Independent journalist Miles Howe says the mainstream news media missed important stories two years ago during protests against hydraulic fracturing near the Mi’kmaq reserve of Elsipogtog north of Moncton. He made his comments on June 11 during a meeting at Parrsboro’s Ottawa House Museum where he talked about his recently published book, Debriefing Elsipogtog: The Anatomy of a Struggle.

Howe, who writes for the Halifax Media Co-op, said he gives mainstream media such as the CBC, CTV and the Irving-owned newspapers a failing grade for their coverage of protests that helped topple New Brunswick’s Conservative government and forced the Texas-based gas company SWN to leave the province.

Howe’s treaty rights story

Howe himself spent months covering the protests full-time, but says mainstream journalists would pop in briefly hoping to get a quick story.

“They’re not well suited to be doing this type of coverage,” he says. “They’re not investing the time necessary to understand the issues.

“There’s this whole claim to objectivity that requires them somehow to ignore that there are treaty rights. You will never find those things spoken about in the mainstream media.”

In his book, for example, Howe tells how the Mi’kmaq Warrior Society successfully used the Treaty of 1752 against the RCMP by arguing that the police were siding with a foreign company threatening “irreparable harm to lands and waters that the Mi’kmaq had never signed away.”

During his talk at Ottawa House, Howe explained that the Warrior Society called the Canadian military in Oromocto in July 2013, then handed the phone to an RCMP corporal who had overseen the seizure of a snowmobile shack the Mi’kmaq had been using to store water and other supplies during one of their blockades against seismic testing.

Howe isn’t sure what was said during the phone conversation, but the results were dramatic. The RCMP packed up and moved out within 20 minutes and SWN stopped its testing for two months.

“The company promises it will be back in September, but that treaty buys them (the protesters) two months of time.”

Acadian community sides with Warrior Society

Debriefing Elsipogtog: The Anatomy of a Struggle eBook: Miles Howe: Amazon.ca: Kindle StoreHowe says that too often, mainstream media portrayed the struggle against fracking as a native issue overlooking the fact that many protesters were Acadian and Anglophone.

In the book he reports, for example, that the media ignored a petition signed by 1,700 people in the municipality of Rogersville. The petition called on the municipality to ask the Warrior Society to serve as its police force to protect the people and their “waters and land from harm.”

Although the mayor refused to act on the petition, it was well known that she continued to be strongly opposed to seismic testing in the area.

As for mainstream reporters, Howe says there’s no way they could hope to get the full story during their brief visits.

“What was CTV doing, what was Global doing, what was CBC doing?” he asks. “Standing around tweeting waiting for something to happen, but in terms of getting into the analysis of the story, I give it an F.”

This entry was posted in Environment and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s